Unicorns: Are They Really the Best Creatures in the Multiverse?

A local expert weighs in

For quadrillions of our earth-years, a battle has raged across multiple universes. It has torn the fabric of time and space (hence black holes), altered the very nature of matter (hence antimatter), and provided an aesthetic framework for an entire generation’s glittery grade-school notebooks.

Three mythical races are locked in a battle for the hearts and minds of mankind, seeking to settle the Ultimate Debate of Life, the Universe, and Everything. The topic: Which are the best? Narwhals, unicorns, or Pegasus?

Fortunately, Charleston has a resident expert on creatures of cosmic importance. You might think that would be Scott Poole, the College of Charleston professor who wrote the nonfiction book Monsters in America and weighed in on sasquatches for a February issue of the City Paper. But when we e-mailed him asking if he could provide some insight, he said there was probably one person who knew even more than he did: Tami Boyce, a West Ashley artist who does photography, design, illustration, and comics.

“She draws an awesome narwhal and could be described as a fan of unicorns (with a side of irony),” he wrote.

Boyce agreed to impart some wisdom on the all-important trilemma that has baffled the greatest minds since antiquity.


“I don’t know, I mean … This is gonna paint me as some freak, like the people in those mockumentaries,” Boyce says. “I don’t know. I definitely like them. I’ve definitely gotten into arguments with people who think that narhwals don’t actually exist, and I know enough to show them they’re real.”

Our sources in the Inuit community confirm that the narwhal is, in fact, a real Arctic-dwelling creature that resembles a beluga whale with a wicked-long helical tusk extending straight out of its jaw (and holy Moses, a select few of them have two tusks). Boyce, who has drawn several single-panel comics involving unicorns and narwhals, has an idea for a graphic novel in which a unicorn pursues a relationship with a narwhal based on the belief that they are both imaginary creatures. The narwhal knows he is real, but he plays along with the unicorn’s idea because he loves her. “It’s some deep shit,” she says.

One last note about narwhals: They’re on the up-and-up, popularity-wise. They’re “indie,” she says. Take note, Pitchfork.


“My take on the unicorn — and I think it’s my age — but it was huge in the ’80s,” Boyce says. “We grew up with Lisa Frank unicorn Trapper Keepers and whatnot … I kind of view the unicorns I draw like washed-up celebrities.”

The unicorn is still a magical beast, even if it has lost some luster since its heyday. One of Boyce’s best-selling prints is a single-panel comic titled “Disappointment and Pancakes,” in which a young girl in a diner looks over to the next booth to see an apparently hungover unicorn holding its head up with a hoof, stubble on its snout and a cigarette dangling from its lips. The caption reads, “Unfortunately, Emma’s first unicorn sighting was less magical than she had imagined.” Boyce says this particular piece has been popular with parents, who often say they’re going to put it up in a child’s bedroom or nursery.

“I think kids don’t really get it,” she says, “but they like it because it’s a unicorn.”


In Boyce’s eyes, the only real battle is between the unicorns and the narwhals. Pegasus, the winged horse of Greek mythology, just isn’t that impressive.

“They seem less magical,” she says. “It’s like, ‘Yes, you can fly, but what else have you got?'”

Nothing, that’s what.

So who’s it going to be, Tami? Let’s decide once and for all.

“Unicorns I think would be the most fun to hang out with, but then in a battle aspect they would probably also win.”

It is settled.

Support the Charleston City Paper

We’ve been covering Charleston since 1997 and plan to be here with the latest and Best of Charleston for many years to come. In a time where local journalism is struggling, the City Paper is investing in the future of Charleston as a place where diverse, engaging views can flourish. We can't do it without our readers. If you'd like to support local, independent journalism:



Best of Charleston 2020

 Just a few more days for you to behold the terrific two-volume Best of Charleston 2020! This week, we’re showcasing the secrets to lifelong health and beauty in Charleston, the city’s awe-inspiring food, most potent drinks and more. As the sun sets on our two-week Best of Charleston, we want to say, “Thank you.” This […]


Feeling COVID-19 impact, Charleston asking for warming shelter volunteers

Due to the coronavirus pandemic, many Charleston locations that have previously hosted warming shelters will not be doing so this winter. But, since the need is still there, the city of Charleston is asking for help. City leaders are asking organized groups, like community clubs or religious groups to help operate a warming center that […]

The Agenda: High turnout exposes problems; Harrison raises $108M to unseat Graham

2020 election expected to bring historic voter turnout, exposes problems. With 772,000 voters already having cast their ballot — either by mail in voting or by in person absentee — the 2020 election is expected to surpass the previous record set in 2016, when 2.1 million votes were counted. However, the turnout has exposed problems […]

SC House justice panel seems to skirt race, critics say

By his account, Marcus McDonald was the youngest person in Room 110 of the Blatt Building at the Statehouse complex when he took the lectern this month.  The 23-year-old Charleston man also lacked law enforcement or attorney credentials — a hallmark of many speaking before the special House Equitable Justice System and Law Enforcement Reform Committee. […]

10/25 COVID-19 update: 11.1% positive, 1,281 cases; 7 deaths

COVID-19 updates: South Carolina health officials reported 1,281 new cases of coronavirus on Sunday, with 7 additional confirmed deaths. With 11,501 on Saturday, the 11.1 percent of tests came back positive. As of 6:57 p.m. Oct. 25, via S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control:Confirmed cases in S.C.:  163,143 (+628)Positive tests in Charleston County (total): 16,576 (+54)Negative tests in S.C.: 1,642,954Deaths […]