The familiarity among the Carla Bley Trio makes for easy listening

Hearing Voices

There’s very little that Carla Bley hasn’t done during her near-60-year career. In the 1960s, the pianist, composer and bandleader was one of the most important figures in the free jazz movement, standing with giants like Ornette Coleman, Pharoah Sanders and Cecil Taylor as they all explored the limits of what jazz, and music in general, could do.

She’s been awarded a Guggenheim fellowship, an NEA Jazz Masters’ award, and created a massive three-album “jazz opera” called Escalator Over The Hill that took three years to make. Her compositions have been recorded by some of the best players of the last 50 years, including guitarists John Scofield and Leo Kottke, trumpeter Art Farmer, and bassist Jaco Pastorius. And she’s worked with big bands, stripped-down duos, and virtually everything in between.

But something special and singular happens with Bley gets together with her collaborators of nearly 30 years, bassist Stephen Swallow and saxophonist Andrew Sheppard. Their musical conversation has gone on for so long that it can almost be viewed as a marriage, something Bley jokes about when talking about their performances.

“The three of us have been playing together for nearly 30 years and, like an old married couple, we finish each other’s sentences as we improvise,” she says. “Music is indeed language, and over time, Andy, Steve and I have become most comfortable together. We’ve learned to breathe together when we play.”

That level of familiarity doesn’t just benefit the trio’s performance; it benefits Bley’s writing, as well.

“Familiarity has a strong effect on the music I write for the trio,” she says. “I hear our voices in my mind’s ear as I compose for us.”

There’s also a certain freedom that Bley, Swallow, and Sheppard have in their playing because the makeup of their trio is so unusual. Without a drummer, they can explore all manner of space that blurs the lines between jazz and classical music, something Bley has done for much of her career.

“I especially relish the conversational flow the trio format allows,” she says, “and I think the absence of a drummer might enhance that aspect of the music. We’re essentially a chamber music ensemble, and this allows me to write music for us free of bombast and exaggeration. Music stripped down to its basic elements. This format also demands that as players, we improvise in the character of each particular song, which is both a challenge and, on a good night, a great satisfaction.”

Whether the night is good or not, improvisation isn’t as big a piece of the puzzle as one might think. As a major figure in free jazz, one might think that Bley enjoys the idea of working without a net, but she’s quick to point out that this trio is a “composer’s band.”

“We know more about what’s going to happen when we walk onstage than many other jazz bands,” she says. “There’s a set list of songs, and we follow it. Each song is a fixed structure.”

The fun comes within the structure, when the trio begins to bob and weave around one another. When Bley talks about that part, the adventurous boundary-breaker in her comes out.

“We love to surprise each other,” she says, “and tug at the limits of form. Ideally, the writing propels us to places we haven’t visited before. We’re always looking for new ways of seeing a piece.”

The “Trios” program at Spoleto will be a mix of old and new. There are actually some pieces they’ll be playing that haven’t been fully fleshed out yet.

“Our concert is a combination of new, not-yet-formed pieces, and ones we’ve played many times over the years,” Bley says. “Paradoxically, it’s often the familiar pieces that are most drastically remade in performance. That reflects my interest in the past: It may be useful in making a better future.”

For Bley, creating material that challenges those performing it is more than just an artistic pursuit, whether she’s playing her compositions, or another artist is taking them on.

“I’ve come to appreciate performances of my music by players of strong personal conviction,” she says. “Performances that honor the spirit more than the letter of what I’ve written. And of course, it’s difficult to lay exclusive claim to spirit. Writing music for improvising musicians should perhaps be seen as service occupation.”

Support the Charleston City Paper

We’ve been covering Charleston since 1997 and plan to be here with the latest and Best of Charleston for many years to come. In a time where local journalism is struggling, the City Paper is investing in the future of Charleston as a place where diverse, engaging views can flourish. We can't do it without our readers. If you'd like to support local, independent journalism:



Chamber Music delights: A midday nibble of classical non-pretense is a perennial favorite, and for good reason

Stephanie Hunt

Ducking out of the midday heat into the enchanted air-conditioned balm of the Dock Street Theatre is true decadence. The space itself — a small jewel box of Old World gleam — is delightfully intimate and inviting, a space somehow imbued with an ambiance of expectation, regardless of what type of performance I attend there. […]


Paper Bullets is the untold true story of queer artists’ campaign to combat Nazi occupiers

Aux Armes Artists Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore took up formidable weapons when the Nazis occupied their small, strategically valuable island home of Jersey off the coast of France: paper and pen.  The romantic and artistic partners used their talents as writers to distribute demoralizing letters to German soldiers during occupation in World War II. […]

City Picks: What we’re seeing, streaming and doing this week

Santa “Sleigh” Ride: Climb aboard a specially decorated carriage driven by the big guy himself for a festive 20-minute ride through downtown Charleston, complete with cocoa, cookies and caroling. Bring a camera for a photo with Santa, Mrs. Claus and the elves, and nestle up in a blanket brought from home and holiday-themed mask for […]

Telehealth expands treatment options in rural areas

Up Close from Afar Sometime in 2016, Charleston doctor Constance Guille was looking at the effect of the national opioid epidemic on the people she knew best — pregnant women — and wondering how to help them. As a reproductive psychiatrist with the Medical University of South Carolina, she knew the stats were dire. “From […]