Spider-Man isn’t just for little boys

The Stupidity of Gendering Our Kids


In our house we’re working on potty training. If you’re still reading after that opening line, I appreciate it. It gets better.

We have a daughter, and one of the things that life with a child reveals is how prevalent gender stereotyping is. And with little kids, it’s almost unavoidable. You go to Target, and the toy aisles are divided: the pink aisle of Barbies, the dark blue aisle of Star Wars and action-adventure toys. No space is assigned for the eight-year-old girl who longs to pilot the Millennium Falcon. But little boys? Star Wars toys galore.

When I was younger, my little brother got an AT-AT for Christmas, the big prowling elephant-like machine that tromped through the snow toward the Rebel base on Hoth. Me? I got a Barbie makeup and hair-styling head. That was fun for about 12 minutes, after which time I chopped off all her hair and went and played with the AT-AT.

This kind of gender differentiation has gotten far more dramatic in the last decade. Now it doesn’t just happen in the toys. It happens with products for which there is absolutely no reason to designate a gender. For instance, sippy cups. Why on earth do we need pink Cinderella sippy cups and blue car sippy cups for kids far too young to have a preference?

Here’s where we return to the potty training. Our daughter Maybelle is learning to use the potty, which means that she’s getting to wear the fabulous motivational item we’re calling “Really Big Girl Underwear.” When we went to the store, we were disappointed to find that the underwear marketed to girls was covered with Disney princesses, fairies, and a completely feminized Dora the Explorer, wearing a skirt and batting her long eyelashes (unlike her very cool androgynous backpack-wearing identity on her TV show). Meanwhile, the underwear marketed to boys had Spider-Man, Batman, and Iron Man on it. And who is Maybelle’s favorite cartoon character? Spider-Man.

I was growling about this to anybody who’d listen, and one of those people was Maybelle’s babysitter Megan. The next time I saw her, Megan handed me a package. In it was girls’ underwear onto which Megan had painted Iron Man, Batman, Spider-Man, lightning bolts for the Flash, and the Star Wars logo. Maybelle now has the coolest underwear anywhere.

In her recent book Cinderella Ate My Daughter, Peggy Orenstein discusses the hyper-feminized products that girls today are exposed to. For example, as of 2011 there were 26,000 different Disney princess items for sale. And these items don’t ultimately promote female empowerment. She points out that “a ream of studies shows that teenage girls and college students who hold conventional beliefs about femininity — especially those that emphasize beauty and pleasing behavior — are less ambitious and more likely to be depressed than their peers. They are also less likely to report that they enjoy sex or insist that their partners use condoms. None of that bodes well for Snow White’s long term mental health.”

Toxic gender stereotypes affect little boys, too. As my feminist Twitter friend Tannis Fuller asks, “If my penis-having child wants to wear a tiara WHY IN THE EVER LOVING HELL WOULD I STOP HIM?” She also points out that his favorite shoes are “pink and blue glitter. That light up when he walks.” And there’s not a thing wrong with that.

Gender stereotypes are no good, and the earlier they start, the more harmful they are. Kids are still learning this whole human-being business. They need toys and books and clothes that allow them to be whoever they are — to play, to experiment, to enlarge our cultural frameworks.

My daughter doesn’t have to be a Snow White. She gets to wear Really Big Girl Underwear and be Spider-Man — at the same time. Tannis Fuller’s son gets to wear sparkly shoes and a tiara. Let’s hope that both kids get to be whoever they are. And that they both get potty trained. I’m kind of stuck on that cultural convention.

Alison Piepmeier is skeptical of gender roles but loves Star Wars.

Support the Charleston City Paper

We’ve been covering Charleston since 1997 and plan to be here with the latest and Best of Charleston for many years to come. In a time where local journalism is struggling, the City Paper is investing in the future of Charleston as a place where diverse, engaging views can flourish. We can't do it without our readers. If you'd like to support local, independent journalism:

UP NEXT FROM

FEATURE

Briggman: I could have been a kid in that Market Street altercation

Christopher Briggman

As a Black male from Pelion — a small South Carolina town with a 97 percent white population — I began working at 15 to assist with family household expenses. Wednesday evening, when I saw a video of Charleston’s beloved Quintin Washington in an altercation, I saw someone who could have been me at that […]


IN CASE YOU MISSED IT

9/27 COVID-19 update: 569 new cases; 3 deaths; 13.8 percent positive

COVID-19 updates: South Carolina health officials reported 569 new cases of coronavirus on Sunday, with three additional confirmed deaths. With 4,118 tests collected, the percent-positive rate was 13.8 percent. As of 6 p.m. Sept. 27, via S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control:Confirmed cases in S.C.:  141,909 (+569 new cases since Saturday)Percent Positive: 13.8% (up from 11%) Positive tests […]

October openings present pandemic-inspired art around Charleston

As the city settles into a new kind of normal during the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, art galleries around town are reopening, both virtually and in-person for socially distant viewing.

LayWills levels up on new EP ‘Upper Class’

Lowcountry rapper LayWills’ sophomore album, Upper Class, is all about the next step up. Taking the formula she laid down in her debut EP PreSchool, LayWills upped the ante on the feel-good party vibe without losing the soul of that last album.

Challengers hope to shift Senate power, Charleston-area seats in play

As Democrats seek to flip four Senate seats in the Lowcountry in the Nov. 3 election, Republicans are looking to wrest five Democratic seats in reddening rural districts in the Upstate and Midlands. Of the Senate’s 46 seats, 27 currently are held by Republicans and 19 are held by Democrats. There are 32 seats facing […]