Softies beg for better wine

Crab Crawling

Spring brings many wonderful things: flowers in bloom, sunny humid-free days, beautiful produce, and glorious sunsets. But amid all this glory, there’s one thing I love more than any other this time of year: the soft-shell crab. Growing up in Maryland, I spent summers devouring blue crab, and I’ve never found a worthy substitute. That is, until I ate my first Charleston soft-shell crab. Locally known as the “softie,” the soft-shell crab is a complete delicacy. The right beverage pairing can take eating softies to a whole new level, whether they’re made into a sandwich, cornmeal dusted and deep fried, or lightly pan sauteed. I grew up enjoying National Bohemian beers during our crab feasts in Maryland, and beer is a natural companion, but the right wine will enhance them too. Together we are going to explore some wine options and which softie preparation will be its best partner.

Grüner Veltliner

Oh Grüner, you have held my heart for some time. This Austrian grape variety is as versatile as it gets. Aromatically seductive and slightly weighty, it brings the palate back to life between bites. Grüner should be given a chance by all wine drinkers, particularly those who love to drink Sauvignon Blanc and Chardonnay. Grüner is affordable and bridges the gap. If your soft-shell crab is made into a softie BLT sandwich or lightly sauteed with butter, ramps, and asparagus, this grape variety is a no-brainer.

Recommended producers: Bernhard Ott, Nikolaihof, Alzinger, Salomon Undhof

Pinot Grigio

Pinot grigio. That’s right, I said it, and we are going to get Charleston back on track. Pinot grigio is one of the great grape varieties of the world. Here’s the problem: this variety has been totally bastardized. Sommeliers young and old have a hard time understanding its greatness, but that’s changing. My favorite pinot grigios come from Friuli and California. Friuli (Friuli–Venezia Giulia) is holding to tradition and continues to honor pinot grigio’s natural tendencies. In California, great pinot grigio is being made in the Russian River Valley of Sonoma. Pinot grigio should be highly aromatic, bright, and refreshing. When you pair it with lightly or deep-fried soft-shells — wowza. Pinot grigio has the body to hold up to the deep fry and offers a slight saltiness to elevate the crab’s flavor. Keep an eye out, the right pinot grigios are out there. While they are not all created equal, a pinot grigio that displays pure terroir is as sensual as it gets.

Recommended producers: Lis Neris (Friuli), Venica & Venica (Friuli), Scarpetta (Friuli), Arbe Garbe (California)

Pink Wine

Known as rosé in America, rosado in Spain, and rosato in Italy, pink wine is what I like to call it, because that’s what it is. Pink wine is primarily released every year at the start of spring. The wine gets its color from the use of red grape skins during the winemaking process. Pink wines can also be sparkling. While pink wines made from cabernet sauvignon, syrah, or sagrantino may produce a fuller body. Most wines are made from or blended with thinner skin and higher acid grape varieties like pinot noir, gamay, cinsault, and grenache. Whether still or sparkling, pink wine is a great companion to any soft-shell crab preparation. Sparkling is well suited for richer preparations, while I prefer a vibrant pink wine with softies that have been sauteed and served with spring vegetables. Either way, the beauty of pink wine is it doesn’t take too much thought. It’s a guaranteed home run pairing with Charleston softies.

Recommended producers: Lioco ‘Indica’ rosé (California), Matthiasson blend (California), Cep rosé of pinot noir (California), Château Pradeaux blend (France), Domaine Tempier blend (France), A. Margain rosé Champagne (France)

Support the Charleston City Paper

We’ve been covering Charleston since 1997 and plan to be here with the latest and Best of Charleston for many years to come. In a time where local journalism is struggling, the City Paper is investing in the future of Charleston as a place where diverse, engaging views can flourish. We can't do it without our readers. If you'd like to support local, independent journalism:



10/30 COVID-19 update: 14.3% positive, 680 cases; 7 deaths

Charleston City Paper Staff

COVID-19 updates: South Carolina health officials reported 680 new cases of the coronavirus on Thursday, with 7 additional confirmed deaths. With 4,743 tests on Thursday, 14.3 percent came back positive. As of 4:50 p.m. Oct. 30, via S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control:Confirmed cases in S.C.:  167,057 (+680)Positive tests in Charleston County (total): 16,774 (+32)Negative tests in S.C.: 1,810,217Deaths in […]


Letters: SC’s modest proposal on race and equity

Editor’s note: Charleston City Paper publishes letters received each week on Saturdays. To submit your own reaction to City Paper coverage or local issues, we welcome letters to the editor. “SC House justice panel seems to skirt race, critics say” answered a question I had since this “task” group was defined by the legislative leadership. Turns out not enough. Here […]

Analysis: Key data show Cunningham as a moderate in Congress

In the race for South Carolina’s 1st Congressional District — including large portions of Charleston — one of the key issues is incumbent Democrat Joe Cunningham’s record during his first two years in Congress. Both Cunningham and his opponent, Republican challenger Nancy Mace, have made competing claims about how to interpret Cunningham’s roll-call votes and […]

Brack: Newspapers have a responsibility to publish opinions, endorsements

Social media and personality-driven television shows that comment constantly on news blur the traditional firewall between news and opinion. As a result, some newspapers are abrogating a traditional role of endorsing candidates during election season. This, we think, is wrong. And kind of lazy. It’s vital in a democratic society for there to be robust […]

James Beard Award-winning author Nathalie Dupree hosts virtual cooking class

Three-time James Beard Award winning author Nathalie Dupree will prepare recipes from celebrated cookbook Charleston Receipts during a virtual class on Friday, Nov. 13.