Knapp: Criticism of NextEra's bid for Santee Cooper off base


Resurrecting the BLRA

As the legislature debates Santee Cooper's future, criticism has been levied against NextEra Energy's offer to buy the state utility.

Selling Santee Cooper to NextEra would relieve ratepayers of a crushing $6.8 billion nuclear and other debt, give back to customers the money already paid for the nuclear project debacle in Fairfield County and lower rates.

Some have accused NextEra's proposal of having the same problems as the Base Load Review Act (BLRA), the 2007 law that enabled SCE&G, and its partner Santee Cooper, to run up billions in cost overruns and years of delay in the failed nuclear construction effort.

I and my organization, the South Carolina Small Business Chamber of Commerce, have significant experience with the BLRA.

In August 2015, I held a press conference with AARP-SC to first raise our concerns about the BLRA.

In July of 2016, my organization co-founded the Stop The Blank Check Coalition. Our mission was to propose amendments to the BLRA so that there would never be a repeat of the SCE&G financial disaster.

Our amendments turned out not to be necessary due to the nuclear project being abandoned in July 2017, and the legislature essentially ended the BLRA for the future.

Now the ghosts of the old BLRA are being resurrected to tarnish NextEra's purchase proposal.

Here are accusations and the facts.

The BLRA did not protect consumers from being responsible for SCE&G cost overruns that ended up being billions before the project was abandoned.

Under NextEra's proposal the utility will recover no construction costs that exceed their requested $2.3 billion for multiple projects.

The BLRA allowed SCE&G to increase rates every year for the project while the nuclear plants were being constructed. Under NextEra's proposal, consumers will not pay for construction until projects are up and running.

The BLRA gave SCE&G the legal right to recover all its costs for the nuclear project – including almost another 10% for SCE&G profits – even if the project was abandoned for any reason.

Fortunately, the utility was sold to Dominion Energy which absorbed much of SCE&G's $5 billion nuclear construction debt but ratepayers are still on the hook for billions.

Under NextEra's proposal, the utility would not be able to recover any construction costs for an abandoned project unless the reason is due to changes in federal laws or regulations that would legally prohibit the project from being completed.

The NextEra critics have raised some other BLRA-related concerns that NextEra has should address.

One of the amendments proposed by our STBC Coalition was to have the SC Office of Regulatory Staff (ORS), which represents the public's interest in utility matters, serve as an advisory-only party to all utility contractual negotiations and decisions under the BLRA.

While NextEra's project costs to be recovered from the consumers are capped, adopting this amendment would give the public more assurance that construction costs are appropriate.

Finally, the legislature should consult with the Public Service Commission and ORS before approving the Return on Equity rate – in other words, profit – requested by NextEra.

Simply put, the NextEra proposal is not the BLRA reincarnated.

Mr. Knapp is the president/CEO of the South Carolina Small Business Chamber of Commerce.

Support the Charleston City Paper

We’ve been covering Charleston since 1997 and plan to be here with the latest and Best of Charleston for many years to come. In a time where local journalism is struggling, the City Paper is investing in the future of Charleston as a place where diverse, engaging views can flourish. We can't do it without our readers. If you'd like to support local, independent journalism:



Lata: Help Charleston restaurants, vote ‘Yes’ on affordable housing ballot questions

Mike Lata

Charleston has become a world-class city, known for its hospitality and charm. The tourism renaissance began in the early 2000s and has carried on to today. Historical sites, first-class hotels and a burgeoning food scene puts Charleston at the top of national lists to visit. However, in order to sustain this level of accomplishment, many […]


Before You Go: New cranes in N. Charleston; Positive rate tops 15%

South Carolina health officials reported 636 new cases of coronavirus Wednesday and 32 additional confirmed deaths.

Marcus Amaker, Charlton Singleton talk justice in music in new series

Charleston poet laureate Marcus Amaker and Charlton Singleton of Gullah band Ranky Tanky will release the first three episodes of their new series “Raising the Volume” on Oct. 28.

More than 1 million SC voters have already cast ballots

South Carolina is approaching half the total record turnout it saw in 2016 from absentee ballots alone with a little less than a week until the polls close for good. In total, nearly a third of registered voters in the state have already cast ballots in the 2020 presidential election. In 2016, 2.1 million votes […]

10/28 COVID-19 update: 15.5% positive, 636 cases; 32 deaths

COVID-19 updates: South Carolina health officials reported 636 new cases of coronavirus on Wednesday, with 32 additional confirmed deaths. With 4,096 tests on Wednesday, 15.5 percent came back positive. As of 1:48 p.m. Oct. 28, via S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control:Confirmed cases in S.C.:  165,477 (+636)Positive tests in Charleston County (total): 16,676 (+27)Negative tests in S.C.: 1,695,189Deaths in S.C. […]