Beatles vs. Stones: a classic rock ‘n’ roll debate

The Tin Roof hosts a local showdown and benefit

You might as well ask: smiles or sneers? Wearing a necktie and shaking daddy’s hand at the front door or slipping away after lights out to look for trouble?

Put more directly, you could ask: Brian Epstein or Andrew Oldman? These were the managers, after all, who groomed each set of boys, helping sculpt their respective public images, especially in the very early days.

And, in the early 1960s, The Beatles were the cheerful, cheeky chaps, always ready for the camera, and The Rolling Stones were the moody, surly bad boys that good girls couldn’t get enough of after they sent their respectable boyfriends off with a peck on the cheek.

Or as Tom Wolfe wrote, “The Beatles want to hold your hand, but the Stones want to burn your town.”

Both bands emerged at a musically fecund time when England was awash in skiffle, blues, R&B, and rock ‘n’ roll. Both featured prominent songwriting duos (Lennon/McCartney and Jagger/Richards). Both rode the leading edge of the British Invasion; they were the shock and awe that readied the battlefield.

Back then, an older generation bemoaning the lost golden age of societal conformity saw little difference between the mop-tops and the shaggy nuts, but among young rock ‘n’ rollers, the question of whether you were a Beatles or Stones fan was the question.

And, to be fair, as long as we’re comparing and contrasting, the lines aren’t exactly so easily drawn. The Beatles dipped their toes in the bad-boy waters on plenty of occasions. Mick Jagger strutted and sneered on stage, but behind the scenes, he was the consummate professional who used his London School of Economics education to keep The Stones rolling along as a money-making business.

The list of all-time classics by both groups goes on and on. “A Hard Day’s Night.” “Let’s Spend the Night Together.” “Help!” “Mother’s Little Helper.” “Ticket to Ride.” “Tumbling Dice.” “Lady Madonna.” “Angie.” Trying to name all the great tunes written by either one of the groups — to say nothing of their famous covers — would make you dizzy as Miss Lizzie.

Among die-hard fans of both groups, the Beatles vs. Stones debate has raged on for well over 40 years. It’s less a question of which group is the “greatest band” — that question would be like comparing apples to oranges — than a question of which style or image best fits your personal groove.

Now, an upcoming benefit show at the Tin Roof will reignite the debate, bringing in a cornucopia of talent for a night of Beatles and Stones covers.

“Lesley Carroll at the Tin Roof came up with the idea,” says organizer Jamie Resch. “There’s going to be a lot of mixing and matching between the groups. We’re encouraging all the acts to dress up and really have fun with it.”

Acts participating in the Beatles vs. Stones showcase include some of Charleston’s busiest roots, folk-rock, and alt-country artists.

Proceeds from the show will benefit Andrew Wall, a close friend of Kentucky Shoes’ mandolin/banjo player Darby Long. Wall was recently diagnosed with an extremely aggressive brain tumor known as glioblastoma. His sudden collapse, hospitalization, and coma have been devastating for the family. (For updates on Andrew Wall, visit

“Hopefully, by the end of the night, we’ll have something substantial we can give to his family,” says Resch. “Many of the family members have to travel to visit him in hospice and that can be hard, financially. We want to help with that if we can.”

Jason A. Zwiker has been going steady with The Stones for years, but will step out for some Beatles on the side.

Support the Charleston City Paper

We’ve been covering Charleston since 1997 and plan to be here with the latest and Best of Charleston for many years to come. In a time where local journalism is struggling, the City Paper is investing in the future of Charleston as a place where diverse, engaging views can flourish. We can't do it without our readers. If you'd like to support local, independent journalism:



Edisto Bluegrass Fest keeps a sold-out crowd happy

Paul Bowers

A bluegrass festival is a rarefied place, where cornball humor is par for the course and all the real rock stars are over 50 years old. The first-ever Edisto Island Bluegrass Festival fit the bill on Saturday, but with a twist: Hometown heroes Shovels & Rope played second-to-last, injecting a little youth and a whole lotta attitude into the proceedings.


SC cases over 2,400 Friday, ‘a pivotal point,’ health officials say

As South Carolina notched the all-time high number of positive coronavirus cases on Friday, state health officials are calling this “a pivotal point in this pandemic” in the state and nationally. On Friday, 2,470 confirmed cases of COVID-19 were reported, with another 90 suspected cases and 29 deaths, according to the state Department of Health […]

Glizzy tells the truth on ‘Revelations’

Rapper Glizzy released the music video for her latest single, “Revelations” on Dec. 2.

12/4 COVID-19 update: 2,470 cases; 23.8% positive; 29 deaths

COVID-19 updates: South Carolina health officials reported 1,754 new cases of the coronavirus on Friday, with 29 additional confirmed deaths. With 11,569 tests reported Friday, 21.4% were positive. As of 4:11 p.m. Dec. 4, via S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control: Confirmed cases in S.C.: 210,995 (+1,754)Positive tests in Charleston County (total): 20,459 (+99)Negative tests in S.C.: 2,439,341Deaths in S.C. from COVID-19: 4,175 […]

‘Let’s figure this out’: Charleston businesswomen leverage social media during the pandemic

One group of Charleston entrepreneurs has been leveraging their connections through women’s s business groups on Instagram and Facebook to find the best ways to stay afloat amid the pandemic. “I just think, as a business owner, it’s nice to get an idea out there,” said Becki Bowman, the local business owner who has headed […]