Scott’s destiny challenged by third party candidates

Six and counting

After popular Charleston politician Tim Scott clinched the GOP nomination for the 1st Congressional District, PBS host Gwen Ifill chose her words carefully. While noting the significance of Scott’s primary victory, Ifill noted that he “could” be the first African-American Republican in Congress since 2003.

Nearly every other outlet was more than happy to call this race four months early. Both The New York Times and Politico said Scott was “poised” to win in November. The Economist surprisingly went with a simple “likely.” At least The Daily Telegraph of London was kind enough to explain South Carolina’s political tarot cards, noting that the 1st District is “a safe Republican seat.”

These media outlets recognize the kind of voter anxiety that will doom the party in power, as well as the highly energized conservative base anxious to get to the polls in November.

And then there’s the viability of the other major party candidate, perennial Democratic nominee Ben Frasier. Hardly present on the campaign trail, he hasn’t inspired much confidence for a spirited campaign, and many in the party establishment are convinced the Maryland businessman doesn’t even live in the district.

It would seem that broader electoral frustrations — as well as specific concerns with the candidates for both the Democrats and Republicans — has opened the floodgates for several third-party campaigns.

“Neither party got what they wanted,” says Libertarian nominee Keith Blandford.

The latest entrant is Working Families Party candidate Rob Groce. Working Families has traditionally supported the Democratic candidate, offering a second line on the ballot to collect more votes, so Groce’s entrance is a recognizable break from business as usual and indicative of the fractured state of this campaign season.

Blandford and Groce are joined by the Green Party’s Robert Dobbs, Independence Party candidate Jimmy Wood, and United Citizens Party nominee M. E. McCullough.

In announcing his campaign, Groce argued his supporters “want an actual representative who will represent everyone. They know I’ll do the job with no partiality and without being subject to improper influence.”

Pulling enough support from the two major parties is a tough sell in any election year, but it’s slightly more palatable this year as Republicans struggle to capitalize on Democratic discontent.

While Groce tries to plant a flag in the middle, Blandford and Wood are also speaking to the issues important to Scott’s right-wing base: smaller government, less taxes, and a 180-degree turn on immigration and healthcare.

There are certainly differences between Libertarians and Republicans — for example, the third party is a frequent critic of GOP war hawks. But Blandford notes that the similarities are what have Republican rank and file voters giving his candidacy another look, with some supporting him under the radar.

“It’s a nice position to be in where they’re so confident,” he says of the Scott camp. “We can sneak in on this.”

Scott will sit down with the third-party challengers for an October debate. But in these dog days of summer, yard signs are back in the garage, and the 1st District race has fallen off the front page as the focus turns to more salacious fare like the statewide gubernatorial race.

It would be good to remember a lesson from Col. Robert Burton’s bid to win the Democratic nomination in June. Burton, who campaigned heavily to party activists, later learned on Primary Day that there was a large number of voters he’d yet to introduce himself to: the majority of them.

Come Nov. 2, writers from the New York Times, Politico, The Economist, and The Daily Telegraph won’t be the ones stepping into the voting booths in the 1st District.

Support the Charleston City Paper

We’ve been covering Charleston since 1997 and plan to be here with the latest and Best of Charleston for many years to come. In a time where local journalism is struggling, the City Paper is investing in the future of Charleston as a place where diverse, engaging views can flourish. We can't do it without our readers. If you'd like to support local, independent journalism:



Before You Go:

Connelly Hardaway

COVID-19 updates: The South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control (DHEC) announced TK new cases of the coronavirus today, bringing the state total to TK. All nursing homes getting tested: This week DHEC announced that it will test all residents and staff members at nursing homes in the state for COVID-19. DHEC director Rick […]


Gaillard Center’s 2020-2021 season features Broadway musicals, chamber orchestras, and an iconic dance company

While so much of the world has seemed to come to a standstill, area arts organizations and venues continue to plan for their upcoming seasons — offering a shimmer of hope at the end of this coronavirus tunnel. The Gaillard Center promises “10 sensational performances” during this upcoming season, including two Lowcountry Broadway premieres.

Brookgreen Gardens opens new outdoor exhibit, “Southern Light,” on May 15

Murrell’s Inlet’s Brookgreen Gardens is currently open, 9:30 a.m.-7 p.m. daily. And, after its original opening date was delayed due to the coronavirus pandemic, Bruce Munro’s massive outdoor light installation, Southern Light, will open to the public on Fri. May 15.

Sam Reynolds

Sam Reynolds, a Lowcountry folk songwriter who now resides in Vermont, released a collection of soft, subtle, and stirring piano instrumentals on May 1 titled Broken Tulips.

Charleston Wine + Food Festival says 2020 event had $19.9 million local economic impact

A survey by the College of Charleston reports that 54% of the 28,000 Charleston Wine + Food attendees were local.